The Trouble With Unsolicited Healing Advice
Whether I post a photo of my skin healing, a hard day, or just a beautiful experience, it doesn’t matter. Within an hour, someone I’ve never met will tell me to try fasting. Or to cut out sugar or dairy. Whatever worked for them, or even for someone they know.
One of my personal favorites is the good old question: “Have you tried coconut oil?” As if a lifetime of trying different things missed the one thing sitting in my kitchen cabinet. I know people mean well. And I used to believe that made it easier to receive.
What unsolicited advice costs after a lifetime with eczema and TSW
It's hard to explain to someone who hasn't lived inside a body like this for as long as they can remember. Before they even had language. It's exhausting. And not because of the advice itself, but because of what it assumes underneath, and how it makes us feel. Somehow, the suggestion assumes that in a lifetime of dealing with atopic dermatitis - and 12 years of topical steroid withdrawal (TSW) - I never once thought to try lotion, diet, or use coconut oil.
That the thought never crossed my mind. Not until a stranger on the internet typed it into a comment box.
It's not just tiring. If I’m being honest, it’s actually a little insulting. Underneath the suggestion is what feels like the same quiet accusation. That I must not be trying hard enough.
That if I were doing the right thing, I wouldn't still be here. Still struggling. Still asking for help at all. As if decades of appointments could be undone by one jar of coconut oil. As if elimination diets, creams that cost more than my rent, and protocols I followed meant nothing.
Why people offer unsolicited healing advice anyway
I don't think people offering this advice mean any harm whatsoever. I think they see suffering and want to fix it. Watching someone suffer without a solution is uncomfortable. Offering something, anything, feels better than offering nothing. I can absolutely understand that.
But comments like these land differently for someone who’s been doing this for decades, even when they're not meant to. They suggest that if we just tried harder, we could heal ourselves out of this. For those of us with severe, chronic skin conditions like atopic dermatitis and TSW, that message doesn't inspire hope. It adds shame on top of an already shame-ridden body.
It also erases something important. Most of us have already tried both the simple and complicated things. We've spent money we didn't have on treatments that didn’t do a thing. We've grieved the healing we were promised that never came.
How to support someone with eczema instead of offering advice
What we need isn't another suggestion. It's an acknowledgment. This can look like:
- Ask before offering advice.
- Believe that we've already tried many things.
- Offer support instead of solutions.
- Trust that we're the experts on our own bodies.
Choosing presence over unsolicited advice
I still get these comments all the time. Fasting, coconut oil, another cream or supplement. The same suggestions, over and over, from strangers who mean well.
I've stopped expecting them to stop. I’ve accepted that they will likely always exist. What has changed, though, is how I respond. I used to feel obligated to explain my entire medical history to a stranger online. Not anymore.
Now, sometimes I say a simple thank you and move on. Other times, I say nothing at all.
Unsolicited advice says more about the person giving it than about me. Most people can't sit with someone else's pain without trying to fix it. That's a hard thing to witness, so they reach for a solution instead. Understandably so. But I don't need my skin fixed by a stranger. I need to be seen.
Advice rarely does that, but presence almost always does.


Join the conversation